0
Anonymous Posted 16 years ago
Grammar
Zero conditionals with "can"
Hi, I need to clarify on this:
Based on my knowledge,
Zero Conditionals (facts)
If you do this, I am able to do that.
When you try, I have hope.
Based on what I read, 'if' with a modal is considered as first conditional. However with the modal 'can' it seems to be more of a zero conditional in particular contexts.
Am I correct? Can these be considered as zero conditionals?
If you do this, I can do that (If you don't, I can't)
When you make lot of noises, I can't study.
Thank you.
Based on my knowledge,
Zero Conditionals (facts)
If you do this, I am able to do that.
When you try, I have hope.
Based on what I read, 'if' with a modal is considered as first conditional. However with the modal 'can' it seems to be more of a zero conditional in particular contexts.
Am I correct? Can these be considered as zero conditionals?
If you do this, I can do that (If you don't, I can't)
When you make lot of noises, I can't study.
Thank you.
Top answer
Yes. It isn't a matter of whether ot not the circumstances are met in the conditional, it's that they're happening at all. When a person is making a lot of noises, you can't study.
- Yes.
- It isn't a matter of whether ot not the circumstances are met in the conditional, it's that they're happening at all.
- When a person is making a lot of noises, you can't study.
- It doesn't say, 'Sometimes when you make a lot of noise, I can't study' It's WHEN, meaning every time, making it a fact.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
1 Answers
0
Yes.
It isn't a matter of whether ot not the circumstances are met in the conditional, it's that they're happening at all.
When a person is making a lot of noises, you can't study. It doesn't say, 'Sometimes when you make a lot of noise, I can't study'
It's WHEN, meaning every time, making it a fact.
It isn't a matter of whether ot not the circumstances are met in the conditional, it's that they're happening at all.
When a person is making a lot of noises, you can't study. It doesn't say, 'Sometimes when you make a lot of noise, I can't study'
It's WHEN, meaning every time, making it a fact.
0
Related Questions