0
Victo Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

Yes?

I did some research and found the following in a Q&A on this site. My question (at the very bottom) is whether the same rule applies to "e.g."

Q. Is it appropriate to add a semicolon before i.e. or e.g.? For example, is it correct to say “by focusing on prevention; i.e., identifying and intervening”?

Chicago: You can use a comma unless the material after the abbreviation starts a new independent clause.

She carried only the essentials, i.e., business cards, lipstick, pepper spray.

She saw to the last two details; i.e., flowers were waiting and the driver kept mum.

In either case a colon, an em dash, or parentheses might also work. And please note that Chicago doesn’t use i.e. or e.g. in running text (though we allow either in parentheses or notes). We use that is or a similar phrase. In many sentences (such as mine), you don’t really need the abbreviation; a colon or dash alone would be better.

That being said, would the same apply with "e.g."? That is, you can use a comma unless the material after the abbreviation starts a new independent clause.

Examples—are these correct?

{No independent clause follows "e.g."; hence, a comma is used before "e.g.," correct?}
He brought some of the essentials, e.g., a laptop, index cards, a stapler, and multiple reference sources.

{An independent clause follows "e.g."; hence, a semicolon is used before "e.g.," correct?}
He purchased some of the essentials that he needed for the project; e.g., he bought a laptop, index cards, a stapler, and several reference works.

Thank you.
  

Top answer

I'm editing a manuscript and want to put this puppy to bed tonight. " if what follows is a complete sentence (independent clause)? , she can sell her two unused Lamborghinis.

  • I'm editing a manuscript and want to put this puppy to bed tonight.
  • " if what follows is a complete sentence (independent clause)?
  • , she can sell her two unused Lamborghinis.
  • , a level, three hammers, and a truckload of sheet rock.
  • ) Thank you.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
I'm editing a manuscript and want to put this puppy to bed tonight.

To sum it up, do we place a semicolon before "e.g." if what follows is a complete sentence (independent clause)?

There are many ways she can earn money for her tuition; e.g., she can sell her two unused Lamborghinis.
(What follows "e.g." is in fact an independent clause, so we'd use a semicolon
0
victodo we place a semicolon before "e.g." if what follows is a complete sentence (independent clause)?
Doing so would make sense and wouldn’t be wrong, though, for some reason, a comma seems to be more usual. Nevertheless, I’d use a semicolon.
0
Semicolon in 1; a comma in 2 -- both for the reasons I've cited, correct?

Thanks, bro.

Related Questions