0
Taka Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

word(s) of reference, again.

0 01blockquote
00 Literature has been, and will continued to be, as long as it exsists, one of the common denominators of human experience 11b10through which 12b10human beings may recognize themselves and converse with each other, no matter how different their professions, their life plans, their geographical and cultural locations, their personal circumstances. 12blockquote
12br
00 Which words does 'through which' refer to, 'human experience' or 'the common denominators'?02br
02br
00 (IMO, it's 'human experience')0-
  

Top answer

02br 02br 00BTW: i want to ask all you guys, does my English sound weired or unnatural to you? thank you0-

  • 02br 02br 00BTW: i want to ask all you guys, does my English sound weired or unnatural to you?
  • thank you0-
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
0me too.02br
02br
00through experience, i think means that get or gain something precious by practising or getting through something relatively tough.02br
02br
00BTW: i want to ask all you guys, does my English sound weired or unnatural to you? thank you0-
0
0It makes a little more sense to me to read it this way: 'Literature has been... one of the common 01b00denominators... through which...'02b02br
02br
00Other common denominators through which human beings may recognize themselves and converse with each other would be: art...TV...movies...music.02br
02br
00I can see the grammatical poss
0
0 01blockquote
00Literature has been, and will continued to be, as long as it exsists, one of the common denominators of human experience through which human beings may recognize themselves and converse with each other, no matter how different their professions, their life plans, their geographical and cultural locations, their personal circumstances. 12br
12br
0
0 00goldmund.02br
01blockquote
00In my opinion «which» refers grammatically to «the common denominators of human experience»12br
12br
10 Broadly speaking, yes. That's correct. But if you were supposed to pinpoint it, which one would you chose, 'the common denominators' or 'human experience'?12br
12br
10 davkett.12br
0
0 I'm an artist. Artists believe in art as a vehicle through which human experience is expressed. Art, in my experience, is a major common denominater through which human experience is made sharable. Human beings are made aware about many things in life through 01b00other individual's experiences... 02b00I venture to add, maybe even primarily so. I couldn't have writte
0
0 00Hum. Very persuasive. Much better than my banal grammar books.02br
02br
00 Everybody here agree with davkett, teachers?02br
02br
01blockquote
00 I'm an artist. 12blockquote
12br
00 Really? What kind of art are you working at?02br
02br
00 0-
0
0 02br
02br
00Dear Taka,02br
02br
00It is not through «human experience» that «human beings may recognize themselves and converse with each other, no matter how different their professions, their life plans, their geographical and cultural locations, their personal circumstances». Such would be tautology. It is through literature. Literature is «one of the
0
0 00Thanks for another persuasive explanation, goldmund.02br
02br
00 Could I ask you again the same question that I posted here before? 02br
02br
00 Where are you from?02br
02br
00 0-
0
0 My opinion, for what it's worth:02br
02br
00What is literature: one of the common denominators (of what? of human experience)02br
02br
00What's the use of these common denominators ? (hence of literature among the others) : through them human being may recognize themselves etc...02br
02br
00So yes, I think "which refers to "the common
0
0Dear Taka,02br
02br
00Once, Mariabronn, Germany. Now, the World. 05002br
02br
00Kind regards,02br
02br
00Goldmund010id1

Related Questions