0
Smarko1983 Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

why simple past in this example?

He decided that I could have the apartment before he (look)  *looked*  at my credit report.

Why is looked the correct answer? Isn't the conjuction before  an indication that we must use past perfect? Also, the meaning of the sentence, according to my logic, points to past perfect.Here is the whole paragraph.

I can't believe I (get) got that apartment. I (submit) submitted my application last week, but I didn't think I had a chance of actually getting it. When I (show) showed up to take a look around, there were at least twenty other people who (arrive) had arrived before me. Most of them (fill, already) had already filled out their applications and were already leaving. The landlord said I could still apply, so I did. I (try) tried to fill out the form, but I couldn't answer half of the questions. They (want) wanted me to include references, but I didn't want to list my previous landlord because I (have) had had some problems with him in the past and I knew he wouldn't recommend me. I (end) ended up listing my father as a reference. It was total luck that he (decide) decided to give me the apartment. It turns out that the landlord and my father (go) had gone to high school together. He decided that I could have the apartment before he (look) looked at my credit report. I really lucked out!
  

Top answer

Before is not always followed by past perfect. In this case, decided is simple past, so looked should be too.

  • Before is not always followed by past perfect.
  • In this case, decided is simple past, so looked should be too.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Before is not always followed by past perfect. In this case, decided is simple past, so looked should be too.
0
smarko1983Why is looked the correct answer? Isn't the conjuction before an indication that we must use past perfect?
No, it is not a must condition.

He did not look at the credit report. Looking at the credit report is not an event here. It never happened, so there is no sequence of actual events which would make the past perfect the r

Related Questions