0
Mike Rose Posted 22 years ago
Grammar
Why "was" not "am"?
I have difficulty understanding the last sentence.
Assume that the white man is inclined to do something which his heart desires: he might want to go into the sunshine, or take his canoe down the river --- most of the time, he will spoil his desire by clinging to the thought: "I was not given time be merry."
Why is the last sentence in the past tense, not in the present tense? I think if the sentense were "I'm not given time to be merry" it would make more sense because then it would mean "I'm too busy to enjoy it."
What do you think?
Assume that the white man is inclined to do something which his heart desires: he might want to go into the sunshine, or take his canoe down the river --- most of the time, he will spoil his desire by clinging to the thought: "I was not given time be merry."
Why is the last sentence in the past tense, not in the present tense? I think if the sentense were "I'm not given time to be merry" it would make more sense because then it would mean "I'm too busy to enjoy it."
What do you think?
Top answer
Okay - think this through. Is time something you HAVE, or is it something you are GIVEN? Usually it is something that you HAVE, but there are circumstances in which you could argue that it is GIVEN - say, if your employer defines the timetable for a project.
- Okay - think this through.
- Is time something you HAVE, or is it something you are GIVEN?
- Usually it is something that you HAVE, but there are circumstances in which you could argue that it is GIVEN - say, if your employer defines the timetable for a project.
- If it was GIVEN to you, then it was given in the PAST.
- You HAVE the time in the present, but it was GIVEN to you in the past.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
3 Answers
0
Okay - think this through. Is time something you HAVE, or is it something you are GIVEN?
Usually it is something that you HAVE, but there are circumstances in which you could argue that it is GIVEN - say, if your employer defines the timetable for a project.
If it was GIVEN to you, then it was given in the PAST. You HAVE the time in the present, but it was GIVEN to you in the
Usually it is something that you HAVE, but there are circumstances in which you could argue that it is GIVEN - say, if your employer defines the timetable for a project.
If it was GIVEN to you, then it was given in the PAST. You HAVE the time in the present, but it was GIVEN to you in the
00
Thank you. I'm beginning to understand, I think.
But then who gave me the time to be merry in the past?
Kamo
But then who gave me the time to be merry in the past?
Kamo
00
Good question Kamo, and who or what is giving us the time to read and consider this now?
I wonder whether he/she/it will give me the sensitivity to enjoy what I am enjoying now further?
I wonder whether he/she/it will give me the sensitivity to enjoy what I am enjoying now further?
0
Related Questions