0
Hsiaoyunh Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Why not?

Do native speakers say something like the following?

1.

A: Do you know any first-aid tips? I hurt my ankle.

B: Why not?

A: Please tell me.

B: First, put ice on your ankle. Second, wrap it with a bandage. Then, keep your ankle higher than your knee. If you still don't feel good, ask someone to take you to the hopstital.

A: Thank you.

2.

A: I won't go to your party.

B: Why not? (I wonder if B can say "Why". )
  

Top answer

It is OK in your second dialogue, but not in your first: 1. A: Do you know any first-aid ? I hurt my ankle.

— Mister Micawber

  • It is OK in your second dialogue, but not in your first: 1.
  • A: Do you know any first-aid ?
  • I hurt my ankle.
  • B: Yes, a bit.
  • First, put ice on your ankle.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
.
It is OK in your second dialogue, but not in your first:

1.

A: Do you know any first-aid? I hurt my ankle.

B: Yes, a bit. First, put ice on your ankle. Second, wrap it with a bandage. Then, keep your ankle higher than your knee. If you still don't feel good, ask someone to take you to the hospital.

A: Thanks!
0
0
hsiaoyunhA: Do you know any first-aid tips? I hurt my ankle.

B: Why not?
No. Answer like that, and they'll look at you like you've got two heads!
hsiaoyunhA: I won't go to your party.

B: Why not?
Fine. "Why?" is also possible, but less common.
CJ
Whoop. Didn't see you there, Mr.
0

Related Questions