0
Lynn3 Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

why is that answer?

two people's converstaion

...

A: Does that mean that there will be no investigation of the accident?

B: No, it doesn't. There will be an investigation.

Q: Why the "B" answer " No, it doesn't. and there will be an investigation."

I think. I should be "yes, it does." Right?

Thanks

Lynn
  

Top answer

Hello Lynn I think "No, it doesn't" is OK. Please consider the dialogue below. " B : "No, it doesn't (mean so)".

  • Hello Lynn I think "No, it doesn't" is OK.
  • Please consider the dialogue below.
  • " B : "No, it doesn't (mean so)".
  • paco
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
Hello Lynn

I think "No, it doesn't" is OK. Please consider the dialogue below.

A : "Does that mean so?"
B : "No, it doesn't (mean so)".

paco
0
'No, it doesn't' is the abbreviated version of 'No, it doesn't mean that there will be no investigation of the accident.' Since the two speakers know what A is asking, there is no need to repeat everything after 'doesn't'. B is correcting A's apparent confusion as to whether or not there will be an investigation. B could also have said simply 'No, there will be an investigation.'
0
Hi,

I'd like to add a general comment.

This slight difficulty in responding when there is more than one negative involved arises quite often. 'Is it true that you are not going to stop denying your lies?'

To deal with this, we often add a comment to our reply, to clarify it. 'Yes, I will not stop denying this'. Al
0
Here's another way of interpreting A and B:

A) Does it mean that there will not be an investigation of the accident?
B) No, it doesn't mean that. It means that there will be an investigation.

Related Questions