0
Hhtt Posted 10 years ago
Vocabulary

Why ever [The role of ever]

In the sentence "why ever you are doing this", what is the role of the "ever" part, i.e is it verb,adverb or subject? What should we call it to be?

Thank you.
  

Top answer

hhtt In the sentence "why ever you are doing this", That is not a natural English sentence. "Ever" is only used in these combinations: what( so)ever who( so)ever however whenever There is no combination of "why" + "ever" except perhaps in regional dialects, where it would be considered an adverb..

  • hhtt In the sentence "why ever you are doing this", That is not a natural English sentence.
  • "Ever" is only used in these combinations: what( so)ever who( so)ever however whenever There is no combination of "why" + "ever" except perhaps in regional dialects, where it would be considered an adverb..
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
hhttIn the sentence "why ever you are doing this",
That is not a natural English sentence.
"Ever" is only used in these combinations:
what( so)ever
who( so)ever
however
whenever

There is no combination of "why" + "ever" except perhaps in regional dialects, where it would be considered an adverb..
0
Could it be a British English usage?

Thank you.
0
Yes, it's a feature of British English.

http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/whyever

It's usually spelled as one word.

Clive
0
hhttCould it be a British English usage?
I am familiar with British English, but not all of its nuances. I speak American English.
0
The graphs below paint a rather different picture. Perhaps they are unrepresentative.

https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=why+ever%3Aeng_gb_2012%
0
CliveYes, it's a feature of British English.http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/whyever It's usually spelled as one word.Clive
When whyever spelled as one word, is the "ever" used there still an adverb and if it is, how can I understand tha
0
hhttWhen whyever spelled as one word, is the "ever" used there still an adverb
When determining parts of speech, we do not dissect a word. The part of speech applies to a whole word, not a part of it.

"Ever" as a word by itself is an adverb.

Will he ever come again?
0
GPYThe graphs below paint a rather different picture. Perhaps they are unrepresentative.https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=why+ever%3Aeng_gb_2012%2Cwhyever%3Aeng_gb_2012%2C+w... I would point out, though, that the origin
0
hhttWhy the original is wrong by any standard when it is supposed to be complete sentece? Clive says that it is a feature of British English to write it as one word. Did you look at this link http://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/whyever ?
Th
0
GPY.There are two separate issues.

It was suggested that "whyever / why ever" is a feature of BrE, and that it is normally written "whyever". The Google Ngrams results that I posted do not support either of those theories. In my experience, "why ever", two words, is common in BrE. That is not to say that "whyever" is wrong. I cannot speak for AmE usage.

Related Questions