0
Abil Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Who or whom?

The follwing is an excerpt from BBC news:

Protesters have been demanding Mr Samak step down for weeks. They say he is a puppet for Thaksin Shinawatra, the former prime minister who the military accused of corruption and ousted in 2006.

My question is: should not it be "whom" instead of "who"?
  

Top answer

Use 'whom'.

  • Use 'whom'.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

15 Answers
0
Use whom; it's the object of the verb accused.

If it were a passive construction, it would be who was accused.
0
AbilMy question is: should not it be "whom" instead of "who"?
Only in overly formal contexts. The way "who" was used is perfectly ok in virtually every context in modern English.
0
Strictly speaking, as Philip also said, 'whom' should be used.
0
Yoong LiatStrictly speaking, as Philip also said, 'whom' should be used.

Yes, but what do you mean by "strictly speaking"?
I think you only need to use "whom" that way if you have a teacher or editor who demands you use it. The use of "who" is now considered perfectly ok in pretty formal contexts too... In fact, the original poster's example cam
0
Kooyeen
Yoong LiatStrictly speaking, as Philip also said, 'whom' should be used.


Yes, but what do you mean by "strictly speaking"?
I think you only need to use "whom" that way if you have a teacher or editor who demands you use it. The use of "who" is now considered perfectly ok in pretty formal contexts too...In fa
0
PhilipSorry, but from what I've been hearing recently, even from so-called respected newscasters, I refuse to hold the news media as a standard! The most intelligent, literate and articulate reporting I've heard in the last many months was, quite unexpectedly, form those reporting the Olympics.

I agree with Philip. Even journalists make mistakes some
0
Well, I don't agree, but in the end, everyone is free to choose their own style. If newscasters and journalists shouldn't be considered as a good standard, if movies aren't good either, if novels and song lyrics are full of "mistakes" and non-standard English, then what is left as a good standard? Only grammar books, it seems, which are taken into account by less than 1% of the native speakers, I
0
Abil posted the question and we've replied. I think it is best left to him to decide whether to use 'who' or 'whom' in the sentence he posted.

Related Questions