0
Anonymous Posted 5 years ago
Grammar

Who he played under

Townsend is reunited with Everton boss Rafael Benitez, who he played under at Newcastle.

I think that who is in the objective case in the non-restrictive relative clause who he played under at Newcastle?

Am I correct?

  

Top answer

anonymous I think that who is in the objective case in the non-restrictive relative clause who he played under at Newcastle? From the viewpoint of semantics, yes, but from the viewpoint of syntax 'who' is a subject case form, and 'whom' is an objective case form. CJ

  • anonymous I think that who is in the objective case in the non-restrictive relative clause who he played under at Newcastle?
  • From the viewpoint of semantics, yes, but from the viewpoint of syntax 'who' is a subject case form, and 'whom' is an objective case form.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
anonymousI think that who is in the objective case in the non-restrictive relative clause who he played under at Newcastle?

From the viewpoint of semantics, yes, but from the viewpoint of syntax 'who' is a subject case form, and 'whom' is an objective case form.

CJ

0
anonymousI think that who is in the objective case in the non-restrictive relative clause who he played under at Newcastle?

Close: it's the object of under, and therefore the objective case whom is more correct (but also more formal).

Related Questions