0
Bee green 672 Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Which Vs Where in RC

1- Houses where a lot of natural light comes in are better for you.

I have read a lot about this topic and come across two rules:

1)

If the place we are talking about is the subject or direct object of the relative clause, then use which or that.

Let's try this:

The relative clause would be:

(A lot of natural light comes in houses) = NOT a Subject NOR an Object

2)

A) If the relative (pronoun / adverb) is replacing:

A noun e.g. The house, use which (The house which I live in is small) RC = ( I live in THE HOUSE)

B) If the relative (pronoun / adverb) is replacing:

A prepositional phrase PP e.g. in the house, use where (The house Where I live is small) RC = ( I live IN THE HOUSE


Keeping these two rules in mind, how would you explain 1 ?

Houses where a lot of natural light comes in are better for you.

  

Top answer

Anyone?

  • Anyone?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
bee green 672Houses where a lot of natural light comes in are better for you.

In my opinion 'where' is not being used literally here. It has little to do with location (even though it follows 'houses', which can be construed as places). It's a construction where the meaning is more like "such that". It's somewhat informal.

Examples:

Related Questions