Which one is so hungry?

sunny123Is the following conversation correct and meaningful?

It is an odd situation to be presented with. What kind of context does this lie within?

Mister Micawber sunny123Is the following conversation correct and meaningful?It is an odd situation to be presented with. What kind of context does this lie within?

The whole conversation is in the following.

Farid: Mom, where are you?
Mom: I’m in the kitchen.
Farid: Hello. Where’s Dad?
Mom: In the garage.
Farid: What’s he doing? I’m s

Farid: Mom, where are you?
Mom: I’m in the kitchen.
Farid: Hi. Where’s Dad?
Mom: In the garage.
Farid: What’s he doing? I’m so hungry.
Mom: Fixing the car. Wash your hands and sit down for lunch. I’ll call your father.
Farid: OK.

*************
Question:

A: Who

Ok, thank you Micawber. Maybe my textbook is a bit wrong. it uses "who" and "which one" in the same situation sometimes.

sunny123. Maybe my textbook is a bit wrong. it uses "who" and "which one" in the same situation sometimes.

You can use 'Which one' in yours too, but as a teacher, I suggest that you do not include the two names—that was my point.

Ok, thank you Micawber. When I used "Which one is so hungry? Farid or his dad?"

I knew that I could use .... "Who is so hungry?" But I prefered to use ""Which one is so hungry?"
because I wanted to understand if my students have learned "which one" either. Then I hope I can use the following to know this.

A: . Which one is so hungry? Farid or his dad?
B: Farid.
Righ

sunny123Right?

You can, but I am recommending—again!—that you omit the names in order to make the question more challenging.

Mister Micawber sunny123Right?You can, but I am recommending—again!—that you omit the names in order to make the question more challenging.

Oh, thank you. Now I get what you mean about the names!