0
Rex Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Which

1.The compnay which has a good reputation as ..........


2.The companies which have a good reputation as ........

I hope my second sentence is fine. I assume the subject is companies so the verb should be 'have'

Please tell me if I am wrong. It is my understanding that the pronoun in similar constructions don't behave as the subject.
  

Top answer

" are correct. the pronoun in similar constructions don't behave as the subject Don't know what you mean here.

  • " are correct.
  • the pronoun in similar constructions don't behave as the subject Don't know what you mean here.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

12 Answers
0
"the company which has ..." and "the companies which have ..." are correct.

the pronoun in similar constructions don't behave as the subject
Don't know what you mean here.
0
Thanks CalifJim for the reply. Let us take another example.

3. The man who was wearing a black suit.......

4. The men who were wearing black suites ......

In the above sentences, the pronouns have nothing to do with the subject. This is my understanding.

0
I don't find any pronoun.

a pronoun is like 'this', 'that', 'she', 'he', etc.
0
"Who" is a relative pronoun, and it has everything to do with the subject (man/men), since it replaces them Emotion: tongue tied

BTW, it
0
Pienne

There are two words and they are 'suit' and 'suite' . I am familiar with the both words.

I thought the plural form should always be 'suites'.

Are you sure on this point?
0
What a man sometimes wears is a suit, plur. "suits".

You can have a "suite" (plur. suites) in a hotel, it's a kind of small flat.
0
So the subject in the first sentence is man and the second sentence it is men.

This is my understanding. Please correct me if I am wrong.
0
Thank you for your correction:-)
0
Concerning the man and the black suit:

the pronouns have nothing to do with the subject
On the contrary, the pronouns (i.e., "who") have everything to do with the subject; they represent the subject in the relative clause.

The man who was wearing a black suit [was the tallest in the room].
= The man (the man was wearing a black su
0
Thanks CalifJim for the reply.

So the pronoun 'who' is a subject. It is the subject of the relative clause.

If you look at the entire sentences, the subject is 'The man' in the first sentence and 'The men' in the second sentence. Please tell me if I am wrong.


What would happen if you just insert a comma? I have a hunch that there is a shift in the meaning

Related Questions