0
Mack&Mack Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

Where've you been? Are you playing tennis?

Dear teachers,

I have a quick question to ask

One of the most common example for 'Present Perct Continuous' I know is as follows:

Where have you been? Have you been playing tennis?

The sentence above is one the most difficult sentences to come out of my mouth when I try to use it since my mother tongue doesn't have that tense. Rather, it sounds like my native language - which is Korean - takes the tense form of 'present continuous'.

What would it sound if I said

"Where have you been? Are you playing tennis?"

Would it sound wierd?

Thanks a lot in advance
  

Top answer

Hello, M&M, The first sentence sounds right to me, especially if the person the question is asked shows up in tennis gear, or/and with a tennis racket in his/her hand. The second one doesn't sound correct. I could imagine saying that in one instance: Your daughter (let's say) hasn't been at home all day - and she should have been there for lunch.

  • Hello, M&M, The first sentence sounds right to me, especially if the person the question is asked shows up in tennis gear, or/and with a tennis racket in his/her hand.
  • The second one doesn't sound correct.
  • I could imagine saying that in one instance: Your daughter (let's say) hasn't been at home all day - and she should have been there for lunch.
  • It's about 6PM.
  • Someone tells you they've seen her at the tennis club.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Hello, M&M,

The first sentence sounds right to me, especially if the person the question is asked shows up in tennis gear, or/and with a tennis racket in his/her hand.

The second one doesn't sound correct. I could imagine saying that in one instance: Your daughter (let's say) hasn't been at home all day - and she should have been there for lunch. It's about 6PM. Someone tells you
0
Thanks a lot Pieanne. I think I have seen your name a lot here and there in this site.

The instance you gave was crystal clear to me. Again, thanks.



May the blessing of *** be on you!"
0
You're right, M&M... I'm finding myself quite addicted to all your questions - and to trying to find an answer for them- Emotion: smile

Related Questions