0
Moon7296 Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Where / which

1. This is only one instance which/where it was not safe to eat genetically engineered foods.

2. Sometimes this caregiving occurs in three-generation households which/where the oldest generation contributes to the household economy.

3. Air transportation is an essential ingredient of tourism development, especially at an international scale which/where destination choices may be constrained by time.

All the answers provided by my book is 'where'. I don't know how to understand and teach this. (My book says the reason the answers are where is the parts after where are complete clauses)
  

Top answer

moon7296 (My book says the reason the answers are where is the parts after where are complete clauses) Whoever wrote your book knows precious little about English syntax. Which can begin a "complete clause" but it is normally the subject or object in that clause while where cannot assume that role. moon7296 1.

  • moon7296 (My book says the reason the answers are where is the parts after where are complete clauses) Whoever wrote your book knows precious little about English syntax.
  • Which can begin a "complete clause" but it is normally the subject or object in that clause while where cannot assume that role.
  • moon7296 1.
  • This is only one instance which/where it was not safe to eat genetically engineered foods.
  • It is the grammatical subject, so having which before it is just plain impossible.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
moon7296(My book says the reason the answers are where is the parts after where are complete clauses)
Whoever wrote your book knows precious little about English syntax. Which can begin a "complete clause" but it is normally the subject or object in that clause while where cannot assume that role.
moon72961. This is o
0
Hi,

I'm preparing an exam to be a public school English teacher. I found I need some strategies to teach English other than things I had done to learn English only for myself.

I understand quite a lot about where/which but need to know more to teach them clearly.

Thank you for your long answer.

Related Questions