0
Stenka25 Posted 12 years ago
Vocabulary

What those pronouns represent?

The following passage is from the website as follows:

http://www.epubbud.com/read.php?g=H8AVF5J5&p=8

Each older man had a trading partner to the south whom he met once a year in the dry season at a ceremonial gathering. In exchange for a dozen sting-ray barbs, to be used as spear tips, he received an axe. In turn he had obtained some of the barbs from his other trading partner to the north – to whom he gave an axe in return. Another 150 miles to the south, the exchange rate was different: one axe for one barb. There were arbitrage profits all along the chain.

Let me give you more context to give you clearer view of this trade. Before the passage above there was a story of a tribe, the Yir Yoront aborigines, each of whose family camp had one highly valued stone axe, which all came from a quarry by the Kalkadoon tribe, far south beyond the Yir Yoront lands, and the axes passed through the hands of many trading partners to reach the Yir Yoront aborigines.

In the passage, ‘he’ of ‘whom he met,’ and ‘he’ of ‘he received an axe’ stand for ‘Each older man.’

The problem comes from next sentence, in a sense of context, the underlined ‘he,’ ‘his,’ and ‘he’ seems to represent the same ‘each older man,’ but in that case that doesn’t make any sense to me. He already exchanged an axe for 12 sting-ray barbs. How is it possible he exchanges ‘some of the barbs’ for his axe with the value of 12 sting-ray barbs. (‘Some’ in this sense means ‘a few,’ right?) He seems to be in a serious deficit in this trade.

Can you tell me how this happened, and what does each of these pronouns, ‘he,’ ‘his,’ and ‘he’ represent?
  

Top answer

In the entire passage, the pronouns refer to one of the older men. Each older man had a trading partner to the south whom he (refers to one of the older men) met once a year in the dry season at a ceremonial gathering. In exchange for a dozen sting-ray barbs, to be used as spear tips, he (refers to one of the older men) received an axe.

  • In the entire passage, the pronouns refer to one of the older men.
  • Each older man had a trading partner to the south whom he (refers to one of the older men) met once a year in the dry season at a ceremonial gathering.
  • In exchange for a dozen sting-ray barbs, to be used as spear tips, he (refers to one of the older men) received an axe.
  • In turn he (refers to one of the older men) had obtained some of the barbs from his (refers to one of the older men) other trading partner to the north – to whom he (refers to one of the older men) gave an axe in return.
  • Another 150 miles to the south, the exchange rate was different: one axe for one barb.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
In the entire passage, the pronouns refer to one of the older men.

Each older man had a trading partner to the south whom he (refers to one of the older men) met once a year in the dry season at a ceremonial gathering. In exchange for a dozen sting-ray barbs, to be used as spear tips, he (refers to one of the older men) received an axe. In turn he (refers to one of the o
0
I agree with AS's analysis. However, the original states that he had received 'some' of his twelve barbs from his partner in the north. This suggests that he received some from elsewhere. It also leaves open the possibility that he received less than twelve barbs from his partner in the north. This would clearly not make sense.

Related Questions