0
Heisenberguncert Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

What rule of English is violated in the following example?

What rule of English is violated in the following example?

"Today's race featured two, difficult climbs."

As a native English speaker, I know that the previous sentence should read "today's race featured two difficult climbs," excluding the comma. However, I cannot satisfy my urge to explain why the example in question is incorrect. After-all, in English we use a comma to separate two adjectives modifying the same noun as in ". . . long, difficult climbs," and "two" is an adjective.

It seems we don't consider cardinal adjectives to be a part of the list of adjectives modifying the noun . . . why not?

  

Top answer

Today's race featured two, difficult climbs . "Two" is not an adjective but a determinative functioning as a determiner, and "difficult" is an adjective modifying "climbs". There is no reason to separate with a comma the determiner and the noun phrase that it determines.

  • Today's race featured two, difficult climbs .
  • "Two" is not an adjective but a determinative functioning as a determiner, and "difficult" is an adjective modifying "climbs".
  • There is no reason to separate with a comma the determiner and the noun phrase that it determines.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Today's race featured two, difficult climbs.

"Two" is not an adjective but a determinative functioning as a determiner, and "difficult" is an adjective modifying "climbs".

There is no reason to separate with a comma the determiner and the noun phrase that it determines.

Related Questions