0
Raen Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

"What needs must"?

I have a couple questions about it:
1) What does it mean?
2) How does the grammar work here? "needs" followed by "must". Is it even grammatical? (it must be, but I don't see it). Thank you.
  

Top answer

Your question is not clear. "needs" followed by "must" can only happen when "needs" is a noun. '

  • Your question is not clear.
  • "needs" followed by "must" can only happen when "needs" is a noun.
  • '
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
Your question is not clear.

"needs" followed by "must" can only happen when "needs" is a noun. 'Their needs must be met.'
0
Could you post the whole sentence?

There is an expression "needs must", meaning that necessity forces one to do something that one might not otherwise be keen to do. I am not aware of any expression "what needs must".
0
RaenHow does the grammar work here?
Forget the grammar. This is a fixed expression from centuries ago, that is, at a time when it was grammatical. "needs must" or "must needs" just means "must", "have to", "has to".

http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/needs-mu
0
CalifJimThis is a fixed expression from centuries ago, that is, at a time when it was grammatical. "needs must" or "must needs" just means "must", "have to", "has to".
Does anyone still say that? I don't recall 'hearing' it currently and wouldn't recommend it to students.
0
canadian45Does anyone still say that?
Not that I know of. I've seen it in writing on a rare occasion, but I don't believe I've ever heard anyone use it in a conversation.

CJ
0
Thanks for the replies. They helped a lot and no, I never intended to use it at any time. I read that off of a page of a novel, British published. (Could that be why?) It confused me (and that was the whole sentence, by the way), that's why I asked. Thank you again.
0
Raenthat was the whole sentence
Then, depending on context, it means:

Whatever you have to do.
Do whatever has to be done.
A person does whatever a person has to do.

Or something similar.

CJ

Related Questions