0
Jazzmaster Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

What does it refer to?

If I read a sentence:

Substance A is placed in substance B, allowing it to do something.


What does "it" refer to? Substance A, substance B or the entire preceding sentence?
Explanation requested.

Thanks in advance

J
  

Top answer

I think "it" refers to substance B [:^)]

  • I think "it" refers to substance B [:^)]
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

10 Answers
0
I think "it" refers to substance B [:^)]
0
Thanks UsamaH,

Can you please provide me with an explanation?

JM
0
It's impossible to say whether the writer meant that A will do something or B will do something. Perhaps it means the A/B mixture.
0
I considered "B" as I thought of it like that:

Substance "B" was firstly alone and is not allowed to do something, but when substance "A" was added, It allowed it (B) to do that thing.

Despite of my explanation, I would rather prefer GrammarGeek's explanation instead.
0
Thanks for stopping by, GG

... How did you know that WAS the answer I was searching for?

Thanks again!

JM
0
Thanks UH for coming through once more

I got your point. Likewise, I like GG's explanation. No matter how grammatically correct it may be, it does not make any sense if we the readers are left confused.

Thanks again.
0
0
jazzmasterNo matter how grammatically correct it may be, it does not make any sense if we the readers are left confused.
jazzmaster, that is the #1, most important rule of ANY writing - make it clear and easy for the reader to know what you meant!

It is more important than any rule of grammar, or any style guide.

Let's say it again!
0
GG, thanks for the overwhelming praise. I am flattered. Come to think of it, I did say it in pretty concise, short and sweet way, did I not?

Sadly, there are so many ESL teachers who are so grammatically narrow minded that they tend to forget the most important rule of all: "Unless readers understand what you are saying loud and clear in one shot, that sentence does not mean $#@*."
0
deleted : accidental double posting

Related Questions