0
SweetFreedom Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Valid reasons to punish?

Does "valid reasons to punish" mean "valid reasons to be punished (for the behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)"?

Context:

One implication of a determined will, Harris says, is that it becomes unreasonable to punish people out of retribution—only behaviour modification and the deterrence of others still seem to be potentially valid reasons to punish.[26] This, especially because behaviour modification is a sort of cure for the evil behaviours; Harris provides a thought experiment:

Consider what would happen if we discovered a cure for human evil. Imagine, for the sake of argument...the cure for psychopathy can be put directly into the food supply like vitamin D...consider, for instance, the prospect of withholding the cure for evil from a murderer as part of his punishment. Would this make any moral sense at all?[26]
  

Top answer

SweetFreedom Does "valid reasons to punish" mean "valid reasons to be punished (for the behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)"? No. I see no reason to interpret this in the passive.

  • SweetFreedom Does "valid reasons to punish" mean "valid reasons to be punished (for the behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)"?
  • No.
  • I see no reason to interpret this in the passive.
  • valid reasons to punish ~ valid reasons (for someone) to [administer / deliver] punishment (upon someone else) CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
SweetFreedomDoes "valid reasons to punish" mean "valid reasons to be punished (for the behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)"?
No. I see no reason to interpret this in the passive.

valid reasons to punish ~ valid reasons (for someone) to [administer / deliver] punishment (upon someone else)

CJ
0
Thanks.
(administer/deliver)punishment (upon someone else for his/her behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)?
0
SweetFreedomThanks.(administer/deliver)punishment (upon someone else for his/her behaviour modification and the deterrence of others)?
No. We don't punish people for their behaviour modification. We punish them for their misdeeds. But we may punish them in order to bring about changes in their behaviour.

only behaviour modification
0
"that still remain" modifies "their misdeeds"? If so, I failed to get "the only reasons ... are to bring about changes..."
0
SweetFreedom"that still remain" modifies "their misdeeds"? If so, I failed to get "the only reasons ... are to bring about changes..."
No. "that still remain" modifies "reasons".

It seems that the only reasons to punish (people for their misdeeds) that still remain

Related Questions