0
Jhilly89 Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Use of semicolon

I have been given a section, and I need to revise the same.

People felt that he had “gone mad” or that the harbored some “secret sin;” while others felt it was “an eccentric whim.”

The revised section

People felt that he had “gone mad” or that he harbored some “secret sin”; while others felt it was “an eccentric whim.”

Are the revisions satisfactory?

Is the semicolon to be replaced by a comma?

If yes, why?

Kindly explain.

  

Top answer

People felt that he had “gone mad” or harbored some “ secret sin”, while others felt it was “an eccentric whim". com/blog/comma-before-while /

  • People felt that he had “gone mad” or harbored some “ secret sin”, while others felt it was “an eccentric whim".
  • com/blog/comma-before-while /
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

People felt that he had “gone mad” or harbored some “secret sin”, while others felt it was “an eccentric whim".

https://www.grammarly.com/blog/comma-before-while/

0

Hhere''s my version. I've deleted the quote marks, although you may wish to replace them if those are indeed direct quotes.

Use a coma istead of a semi-colon. What follows a semi-colon must be able to work as a stand-alone sentence. while begins a subordinate clause.

People felt that he had gone mad or that the he harbored some secret sin, while oth

Related Questions