0
Jhilly89 Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Use of semicolon

I have been provided with a piece of text, wherein I have to identify and eliminate grammatical errors.

The original section:

An idea struck me. I would make a bold move. I boarded the evening train for Dubuque without ticket or money, but with a nice collection of lies. When the conductor came along I told him I was a typesetter on the Dubuque Herald; that I had come to Rockford on business and while there was robbed of my railroad ticket and all my money, and that if he would carry me to Dubuque I was sure the paper would fix things up.

The revised section:

An idea struck me. I would make a bold move. I boarded the evening train for Dubuque without ticket or money but (delete ,) with a nice collection of lies. When the conductor came along, (add ,) I told him I was a typesetter on the Dubuque Herald; that I had come to Rockford on business and while there was robbed of my railroad ticket and all my money; (add ; ) and that if he would carry me to Dubuque, (add ,) I was sure the paper would fix things up.

Is the semicolon after "Dubuque Herald" (marked in bold) to be replaced by a comma?

Should a comma be included after "and" in "and while there"?

Should a comma be included after "there" in "and while there"?

Kindly explain.

  

Top answer

jhilly89 I have been provided with a piece of text, wherein I have to identify and eliminate grammatical errors. Although punctuation errors can in some cases make a sentence appear ungrammatical, they are not really grammatical errors. There are no glaring punctuation errors in the original text.

  • jhilly89 I have been provided with a piece of text, wherein I have to identify and eliminate grammatical errors.
  • Although punctuation errors can in some cases make a sentence appear ungrammatical, they are not really grammatical errors.
  • There are no glaring punctuation errors in the original text.
  • It is questionable whether there are any errors at all.
  • However, your changes are reasonable too.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
jhilly89I have been provided with a piece of text, wherein I have to identify and eliminate grammatical errors.

Although punctuation errors can in some cases make a sentence appear ungrammatical, they are not really grammatical errors.

There are no glaring punctuation errors in the original text. It is questionable whether there are any errors

Related Questions