0
Anonymous Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Use of indefinite pronoun Any

Which one is correct:

Has any of you faxed this document?

or

Have any of you faxed this document?

On one hand, "any of you" should be singular. For example, "Any of you can take his or her pen." On the other hand, "any of you" stands for you. And with the pronoun "you" we always use Have.

Most native english speakers say that "Have any of you" sounds correct.
  

Top answer

I agree with the native speakers: Have any of you faxed this document?

  • I agree with the native speakers: Have any of you faxed this document?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

10 Answers
0
I agree with the native speakers: Emotion: smile
Have any of you faxed this document?
0
While "Have any of you..." does sound better to the ear, that's really only the result of rampant misuse, to which, I confess, I often contribute. "Has any of you faxed this document" is the technically correct form, much as "None of you is cute" is the correct form of the more common "None of you are..." The reason is that none and any are singular indefinite pronouns. "None" is more obviou
0
"Has any of you faxed this document" is the technically correct form
Has none of us noticed this before?

CJ
0
But what about the fact that in the question you are refering to "any one of YOU." You wouldn't say to each of the individuals "Has you done it?" So when you are using indefinite pronoun, it is supposed to take the form of the underlying noun. "any of you" is singular, but it stands in place of "YOU." So sholdn't it still be "Have any of you (YOU) faxed the document?
0
Yes, it should be 'have any of you'.
0
Can you explain why it should be "Have any of you?"
0
I think there's only one person at a time faxing a document, there's no need for moreEmotion: smile

I'm voting for has.
0
But even in singular, you takes have, not has.

Have you faxed the document?

You have? Thank goodness for that.
0
Nona The BritBut even in singular, you takes have, not has.

Have you faxed the document?

You have? Thank goodness for that.
I thought about it, and you're right, if you look at it that way:

28,300 for "Have any of you done"
272 for "Has any of you done"

and

147 for "Have any of
0
I'm voting for 'HAS' if the sentence is "Has any of you faxed the document?". The pronoun 'any' can be used as singular and plural. It depends on the context of the sentence. In this case, 'any' is used as a collective form of the persons that could possibly faxed the document, it should be used as a singular indefinite pronoun; the pronoun 'you' can be both a singular and plural (2nd person); an

Related Questions