0
Anonymous Posted 17 years ago
Linguistics Studies

Use commas well

Commas are overused. A good writer only uses commas when /he/she wants readers to hear the intonation curves in his/her writing. Do you agree?
  

Top answer

No.

  • No.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
Any elaboration would be welcomed, MrM. Like to say more?
0
Why do you feel that, MrM?
0
To an extent, yes.

No one should lay down the law with hard and fast rules about punctuation.
0
Well, I'm not really talking about rules, just good style and skill.
0
There are clear instances of over-punctuation and others of under-punctuation. In between it is a matter of style and preference. When in doubt, listening to the countours of how the sentence would be spoken can be a good guide, but not an infallible one. Sometimes I write something and a comma goes in and comes out because I cannot decide if it helps or hinders.
0
Listening to the contours of the sentence, can lead to pointless pointing.

As there.

MrP


____


Edit:


Footnote for the benefit of Anon (see below):


"Pointing" = "punctuation".


The comma after "sentence" marks the natural pause, and thus reflects the contours of the sentence, but is redundant.
0
.
MrPedanticListening to the contours of the sentence, can lead to pointless pointing.

As there.

MrP

Not sure what you mean there, old chap

0
<Sometimes I write something and a comma goes in and comes out because I cannot decide if it helps or hinders.>

Isn't that just a matter of knowing the way you want to say something. In the above case, it seems you wouldn't have decided how to say a certain thing.

Related Questions