0
Stenka25 Posted 3 years ago
Vocabulary

Use and purpose of ‘Examin’d’

The passage below is from A History of the Index by Dennis Duncan.



At the beginning of the eighteenth century British politics was arranged broadly into two factions, the Tories and the Whigs. At the heart of their contentions was a bitter disagreement over the role of the monarchy, and over the status of the Stuart royal line, a Catholic dynasty, deposed in the Glorious Revolution of 1688/ Much of the public skirmishing between the two factions was conducted through the medium of the political pamphlet, a rough-and-tumble warfare in which pamphleteers were always acidic, regularly anonymous and sometimes ventriloquized their enemies to make them seem rabid, obtuse or both. Into this febrile publishing environment came the mock index. Here a book by a figure of one persuasion would be treated to an index compiled by someone of the other (persuasion), with entries designed to ridicule the main text, to draw attention to its moments of banality or pompousness, its sympathy for foreigners or Catholics, or sometimes even just its sloppy grammar. Macaulay may have thundered at such indexes, fearing that – even in the mid nineteenth century – he might fall victim to one himself, but he was also able to concede their genius. In his own library – and now preserved at the Bodleian in Oxford – he possessed a satirical work from 1698 which featured as its climax a spectacularly derisive index. The work, attributed to Charles Boyle, was entitled Dr Bentley’s Dissertations on the Epistles of Phalaris, Examin’d, and on its rear flyleaf, in a page of scrawling, pencilled annotation, Macaulay has declared it ‘a masterpiece in its way’. In order to understand why Macaulay should have considered this satire a masterpiece – and why he would qualify that appraisal by adding ‘in its way’ –let us turn to our first bout: Boyle vs Bentley.


I think I know the literal meaning of ‘Examin’d’, that is, ‘examine’ means ‘to look at/up/into something carefully and thoroughly’.

But when I googled about ‘Examin’d’, I found out it is usually used in books published about two or three hundred years ago. Is putting ‘Examin’d’ in the end of a book’s title was just a kind of fashion of that age as a way of raising up its credibility, that is, bragging about the book that it is thoroughly examined?


Thanks in advance.

  

Top answer

Stenka25 I think I know the literal meaning of ‘Examin’d’, that is, ‘examine’ means ‘to look at/up/into something carefully and thoroughly’. Correct. Stenka25 Is putting ‘Examin’d’ in the end of a book’s title was just a kind of fashion of that age as a way of raising up its credibility, that is, bragging about the book that it is thoroughly examined?

  • Stenka25 I think I know the literal meaning of ‘Examin’d’, that is, ‘examine’ means ‘to look at/up/into something carefully and thoroughly’.
  • Correct.
  • Stenka25 Is putting ‘Examin’d’ in the end of a book’s title was just a kind of fashion of that age as a way of raising up its credibility, that is, bragging about the book that it is thoroughly examined?
  • It may have been the fashion of the time, but I doubt it had to do with bragging about anything.
  • Stay tuned for more answers from people who are more familiar with the literature of that long-gone time.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Stenka25I think I know the literal meaning of ‘Examin’d’, that is, ‘examine’ means ‘to look at/up/into something carefully and thoroughly’.

Correct.

Stenka25Is putting ‘Examin’d’ in the end of a book’s title was just a kind of fashion of that age as a way of raising up its credibility, that is, bragging about the book that it is
0

Boyle put out a copy of Bentley's book with a "derisive index". He put "examined" at the end of the original title to say that he would be scrutinizing Bentley's work. I don't think we can appreciate how loaded the word was for them. "Examine" has many definitions, for example, "to check for defects, faults, etc." (OED), some of the more pointed now obsolete, such as "to interrogate under tort

0

It is a very common word used in a title or a treatise, discussion, or analysis of some subject matter or another author's work.

https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=examin%27d

The contraction is also typical. For example, here is a passage from Hume's Treatise on Human Nature. All t

Related Questions