0
Nakool Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

Usage of but

All, but here, had made an attempt.

a) All, but she
b) All, but herself
c) All, but she herself
d) All, but her

Ans:- a

Can anyone tell me when we can use 'she or he' and when 'him or her' with 'but' ?
  

Top answer

In this sentence, the word "all" is the subject of the sentence, and is thus in the nominative case. " From this, it can be seen that the word in the blank is the subject of its sentence, and thus is in the nominative case. "She" is the nominative form of the third person singular feminine personal pronoun.

  • In this sentence, the word "all" is the subject of the sentence, and is thus in the nominative case.
  • " From this, it can be seen that the word in the blank is the subject of its sentence, and thus is in the nominative case.
  • "She" is the nominative form of the third person singular feminine personal pronoun.
  • So "she" is the best of the four choices.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
In this sentence, the word "all" is the subject of the sentence, and is thus in the nominative case. The word "but" here means "except." So the sentence means: "All (the people), except ____, had made an attempt."

This is equivalent to two sentences: "All (the people) had made an attempt." and "_____ had not made an attempt." From this, it can be seen that the word in the blank i
0
This is not a very natural sentence.

But is a preposition in the sentence. It means "except" or "except for"
The object of a preposition is always in object case.

If you put the propositional phrase at the end, rather than after the subject, the answer will be more clear.
All (of them) had made an attempt except for / but her.

If but were used as
0
Hi AlpheccaStars,

However, if we are given the above sentence in the exam,should we choose (D)?
0
Hi AlpheccaStars,

Could you please answer my question?

Thank you

Related Questions