0
Clee62 Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

Topic sentence

Hi

I have several just came to me.

First, I was reading a book called Water For Elephants by Sara Gruen. On the side cover (is that the right name?), it said,"..., I've never told a blessed soul." Here is the question: do we say blessed like "blessid" or "blesst"? And do we pronounce the same way when we say," She is blessed."?

Second, when I just started reading this book, I found there are many hard words. Since I don't have any resources to tell how to read efficiently or what is the best reading strategy for reading novels for college students (or ESL students if there is any differences), even though reading this book is for my own good, I hope someone can help me out. I am not sure which discipline of English teacher can best answer this question. No offence if anybody is offened. I have tried to look up the words after finishing like 4 to 5 pages but a friend of mine told me that we should guess the words and read at least a chapter before check up the words since the stops can affect the reading tempo ( i am not sure what that is called).

Third, I happened to do this book. Here is paragraph that has an implied topic sentence:

"Just inside the door of Filene's Basement, Boston's famous bargain clothing store, giant hanging signs explain that the longer an item remains in the store, the cheaper it becomes. All around the walls, floor-to ceiling racks are crammed with a random mix of shoes, sneakers, neckties, and handbags. Counters are cluttered with rhinestone rings, plastic sungalsses, and silk scarves. In the center of the floor, huge suare bins contain disorganized piles of shoes and clothes. Customers dig into these jumbled bins, pulling out yellow rain hats, pink suede pumps, even cheese graters and other items that belong in a kitchen department. Friends lose each other in the crowded aisles. Frantic shoppers often collide as items fly into the air. Some customers question whether any bargain makes this chaos worthwhile, but they always seem to return."

After I finished reading this, there is a question below it and it asked," The main idea of the paragraph is implied, not stated by a topic sentence. What is the main idea?

I went to ask teacher and he said the highlighted clause meant," the main idea of the paragraph is not stated by a topic sentence, and this is also meaning that the topic sentence is not provided."

However, I don't know if there is a gap for my English. I don't get how the teacher determine from the question that the topic sentence is not stated, only thing i know is that the main idea is not stated by a topic sentence. I am just wondering if the question (or the first highlighted part) has implied that the topic sentence is not provided by the paragraph. If it does, could you explain how it was implied.

Many thanks,
  

Top answer

-- Don't use your dictionary too often, but don't wait too long to use it if you don't understand the meaning at all after a page or two. I don't get how the teacher determine from the question that the topic sentence is not stated, only thing i know is that the main idea is not stated by a topic sentence. I am just wondering if the question (or the first highlighted part) has implied that the topic sentence is not provided by the paragraph.

  • -- Don't use your dictionary too often, but don't wait too long to use it if you don't understand the meaning at all after a page or two.
  • I don't get how the teacher determine from the question that the topic sentence is not stated, only thing i know is that the main idea is not stated by a topic sentence.
  • I am just wondering if the question (or the first highlighted part) has implied that the topic sentence is not provided by the paragraph.
  • -- Your explanation is terribly confused, and I am not sure what you think.
  • This is true: there is no topic sentence in that paragraph .
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
On the cover/ In the blurb it said,"..., I've never told a blessed soul."
Do we say blessed like "blessid"?-- Yes

And do we pronounce the same way when we say," She is blessed."?-- No; "blesst"

a friend of mine told me that we should guess the words and read at least a chapter before check up the words since the stops can affect the reading tempo.--
0
Hi,

Sorry for my explanation. What i meant was it seemed that my teacher could determine that the topic sentence was not stated but implied in the setence by just looking at the sentence, which is (is this the right tense?) "The main idea of this paragraph is implied, not stated by a topic sentence."
Does this sentence say the topic sentence is not stated by the sentence?

0
Not stated = not stated:

"The main idea of this paragraph is implied, not stated by a topic sentence." = this sentence say the topic sentence is not stated by the sentence
0
Hi

Thanks for reply. I knew the topic sentence was only implied in the paragraph but the logic behind your derivation was not very clear. Is it becaue you know the main idea has to be stated by a topic sentence, and, in the case, it is implied "only", so the topic setence was not stated in the paragraph.

I am so sorry for the inconvenience but being a scientist makes me want t
0
the main idea has to be stated by a topic sentence
This is not true exactly; it is merely that the paragraph presumably has a topic. I can compose a paragraph that has no topic, but it would be a poor one or meaningless:

I went to the city today. My bed was very uncomfortable last night, so I wrote a book. The bird's nest under the eaves has been abandoned. I guess

Related Questions