0
Diotima Posted 10 years ago
Vocabulary

to suggest that - struggling with subjunctive

I am writing a report and I am struggling with the verb "to suggest". If I am not wrong, the verb should require the subjunctive but I am not sure how to handle these two sentences:

1) I suggest that he pour the liquid holding the container with two hands
2) I suggested that he pour or poured the the liquid holding the container with two hands.

Thank you for your help!
  

Top answer

1) I suggest that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands. 2) I suggest ed that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands

  • 1) I suggest that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands.
  • 2) I suggest ed that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
1) I suggest that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands.

2) I suggested that he pour the liquid while holding the container with two hands
0
(The following is US usage.)

1. The given sentence is okay grammatically, but the context would have to fit. Some examples of correct usage:

A: He's only 4 yrs. old. Do you think he can manage pouring the liquid?
B: (If he's only 4) I suggest that he pour the liquid holding the container with two hands.

C: In this section of the video the child is having troubl
0
You are probably correct about the subjunctive, but there is a better solution,namely the -ing structure:
I suggest pouring the liquid while holding the container with both hands.
0
That is a good idea. What I find more difficult is in the past tense though.
Would "I suggested pouring the liquid..." be ok
0
diotimaMy mother tongue has a present and past subjunctive and it usually changes according to the tense of the main verb.
Ah! That could be a problem then. You'll have to train yourself to use just the mandative construction (~ present subjunctive) no matter what tense the main verb has. This is one reason why it is probably better to say that English has
0
diotimaWould "I suggested pouring the liquid..." be ok
Yes. The -ing word has no tense of its own; only the main verb that precedes it carries tense.

I [suggest / suggested / will suggest / would suggest / have suggested / had suggested] pouring ....

CJ
0
wow, thank you for the clarifications, very helpful! Emotion: star
0
Grammatically correct, but 'suggest tht' sounds a bit clumsy. Much better English with an -ing structure, e.g.
I suggest / suggested pouring out the liquid while holding the container with both hands.

Related Questions