0
MUSCOVITE Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

to give smb smth

Hi,

Following is a sentence from George Orwell's Animal farm:

Major's speech had given to the more intelligent animals on the farm a completely new outlook on life.

Could somebody please explain why the 'to' is used after the past participle 'given'?

Thank you

mus-te
  

Top answer

It is simple: we give things to people, just as we go to places or talk to our wives. That is the way those verbs work.

  • It is simple: we give things to people, just as we go to places or talk to our wives.
  • That is the way those verbs work.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
It is simple: we give things to people, just as we go to places or talk to our wives. That is the way those verbs work.
0
Sorry...if you could elaborate on this piece of grammar?
Mister Micawberwe give things to people
Lets consider

'we give things to people' (A) and 'we give people things' (B)

I understand (A) and (B) are both OK?

Next, which of the following versions are correct grammar:

(a) MM gives some advice to a
0
Yes to everything but this:

MM gives (to) an English learner some advice.

The 'to' is optional but is usually omitted unless the 'something' and/or the 'someone' in the sentence is too long to be easily manageable. In your original, these are a bit hard to wade through for the reader:

Major's speech had given the more intelligent animals on the farm a c
0
Understood. No more followup questions! Thanks a lot!
0
The "to" could be omitted and the sentence would still be grammatical, but the "to" gives rhythm and emphasis to the sentence. You often give something to someone, rather than simply give someone something, so the "to" gives emphasis to the action of giving, which is what the author wants here. Also, "to" improves the rhythm of the sentence; it just sounds better with the "to" in it.
0
Anonymousso the "to" gives emphasis to the action of giving,
It is a very interesting nuance... English textbooks hardly ever point out such "subtleties"...
Thank you, Anonymous!

Related Questions