0
Will Leung Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

"those" not followed by "who"

"Every era is defined by the collective cry of those denied their humanity."

I am not sure abt the meaning. I am confused by the absence of "who" after "those".

Can I just interpret it as : " ... cry of those whose humanity was denied." ?

Thx

  

Top answer

[1] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those who are denied their humanity . [2] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those denied their humanity. This pair are semantically similar, though the clauses modifying "those" are different.

  • [1] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those who are denied their humanity .
  • [2] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those denied their humanity.
  • This pair are semantically similar, though the clauses modifying "those" are different.
  • In [1] the underlined element is a relative clause, while in [2] it is a past-participial clause.
  • g.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

[1] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those who are denied their humanity.

[2] Every era is defined by the collective cry of those denied their humanity.


This pair are semantically similar, though the clauses modifying "those" are different.

In [1] the underlined element is a relative clause, while in [2] it is a past-participial c

Related Questions