0
Johnson13 Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

this word is a slang

SLANG is said to be an uncountable noun, and an American told me we should not say 'a slang', but for

this word is a slang

I think this is at least grammatical, because it is simply ellipsis:

this word is a slang [word]

only that it is not idiomatic, but its grammaticality is acceptable; what do you think?
  

Top answer

You can't say 'This word is a slang''. Say eg This word is slang . If you speak of a slang , it sounds like a whole set of words , eg East Londoners speak a slang that is not used in any other part of Britain.

  • You can't say 'This word is a slang''.
  • Say eg This word is slang .
  • If you speak of a slang , it sounds like a whole set of words , eg East Londoners speak a slang that is not used in any other part of Britain.
  • Clive
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
You can't say 'This word is a slang''.
Say eg This word is slang.

If you speak of a slang, it sounds like a whole set of words, eg East Londoners speak a slang that is not used in any other part of Britain.

Clive
0
Johnson13what do you think?
It’s just wrong.
0
Thanks.

According to your example sentence, does it mean the uncountable DICTION can be used like this?:

That arrives in the world with an already established diction and her own unique sensibility.
0
I don't understand what you are trying to say. What does 'that' refer to?

Your sentence seems to suggest there is some connection between its two parts, but I don't see any connetion.

Clive
0
Sorry~~

You said A SLANG means a set of slang words; then does it mean A DICTION can mean a particular set of words?

Akhmatova was unusual among modern Russian poets in that she arrived in the world "with an already established diction and her own unique sensibility.
0
Johnson13Sorry~~You said A SLANG means a set of slang words; then does it mean A DICTION can mean a particular set of words?Akhmatova was unusual among modern Russian poets in that she arrived in the world "with an already established diction and her own unique sensibility.
In addition: (I think Brodsky's is correct, but I'm not sure whether it's common usage.
0
No, 'dictions' is definitely not common, everyday usage.

Clive

Related Questions