0
Listenever Posted 10 years ago
Speech & Pronunciation

They be gross.



At 0:43, a reporter asks a little girl:
What do people who are in love with each other do?

The girl replies: They be gross.

Is this what the girl actually said?
  

Top answer

Is this what the girl actually said? Yes, that's right.

  • Is this what the girl actually said?
  • Yes, that's right.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

19 Answers
0
listeneverThe girl replies: They be gross.Is this what the girl actually said?
Yes, that's right.
0
Does she mean 'they are gross'?
0
Well, I've got another question.
At 1:25, the reporter said something like "_________ right?" Followed by a girl saying "It was funny."
What did the reporter say in the blank?
0
listeneverDoes she mean 'they are gross'?
They behave in a "gross" manner.
0
listeneverWhat did the reporter say in the blank?
Hard to tell. The laugh track drowns out the reporter's voice.
0
AlpheccaStarsThey behave in a "gross" manner.
Thanks. Is 'they be gross' natural or is it what only kids can say?
0
AlpheccaStarsHard to tell. The laugh track drowns out the reporter's voice.
I hear something like 'up here'. Does that make sense to you at all?
0
listenever Is 'they be gross' natural
It is natural in African-American Vernacular English, and other dialects.
It is considered an error in standard English.
0
AlpheccaStarsIt is considered an error in standard English.
I don't think so here. The child is asked 'What do they do?' and she answers naturally 'They be gross' (= 'they act gross'). It is similar to e.g. 'What do cowards do when confronted?' — 'They be silent' or 'They be afraid'.
0
Mister Micawber'They be silent' or 'They be afraid'.
I wouldn't want an English learner to get into this pattern.
As stand-alone sentences, they be on a slippery slope to the first ring of grammatical purgatory.

Related Questions