0
Reegis Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

There's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall.

Hello.

1) There's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall.

Is this sentence grammatically correct? Especially I am not sure about "who" (can 'tribe' be who and plural?) and I am considering to replace it with "where all people":

2) There's a tribe in Africa where all people are all less than four feet tall.

Does it sound better?
  

Top answer

Reegis There's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall. "Of people" is implied in that sentence. a tribe = a tribe of people.

  • Reegis There's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall.
  • "Of people" is implied in that sentence.
  • a tribe = a tribe of people.
  • Alternatively try, There's a tribe in Africa whose people/members are all less than four feet tall.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
ReegisThere's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall.
"Of people" is implied in that sentence.
a tribe = a tribe of people.

Alternatively try,
There's a tribe in Africa whose people/members are all less than four feet tall.
0
teechr"Of people" is implied in that sentence.a tribe = a tribe of people.
You mean that this sentence is correct as it is? Even without explicitly adding 'of people'?

To sum up:
1) There's a tribe in Africa who are all less than four feet tall.
2) There's a tribe in Africa where all people are all less than four feet tall.
3
0
#2 shouldn't have two instances of "all."
0
Thanks teechr, now it is clear.

Related Questions