0
Ghost Writer Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Then the question is...

When writing out statements that later lead to a question, how does a person introduce the question to the read in a grammatically correct way?

Example:
But if there is no such thing as a permanent self or soul, then the obvious question is - who is this person that eats, drinks, breathes, thinks, forms relationships and has a career?
(source: http://buddhism.about.com/library/weekly/aa070702a.htm)

This quote uses a statement, but importantly "the obvious question is..."

What is the correct way to lead onto a question when using a statement? Is the dash or hyphen the correct punctuation to use?

I've been using the colon along with dependent and independent claues:

Ex:
...then this leads to an obvious question: Who is this person that eats, drinks...?
  

Top answer

The colon is more formal; the m-dash is gaining in popularity, though. "

  • The colon is more formal; the m-dash is gaining in popularity, though.
  • "
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
The colon is more formal; the m-dash is gaining in popularity, though. Or, why use any mark?-- The obvious question is "Who is this person?"

0
I've even seen it without the quotation marks, in a structure I've heard described as semi-indirect quotation. Or was it semi-direct?

... obvious question is who is this person that ...

Indirect would have the is at the end, but this is awkward because it separates who and is by such a heavy structure.

CJ
0
Hi guys,

But if there is no such thing as a permanent self or soul, then the obvious question is - who is this person that eats, drinks, breathes, thinks, forms relationships and has a career?

In reported speech, trying to keep as much of your wording as possible, I would say

But if there is no such thing as a permanent

Related Questions