0
Anonymous Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

then, past tense or present perfect

Which one is correct?
Last september I went back home.
1. Sorry I haven't called you then. Or 2. Sorry I didn't call you then.
I think 2 is correct, but my teacher says 1 is correct ,because "then" means "since then". I don't think so. It says "then", not "since then".
Can you help me, please?
  

Top answer

There are two possible meanings of "then" here. One is "at that time" and the other is "in that case" or "therefore". "Sorry I haven't called you then" is not possible in the first meaning.

  • There are two possible meanings of "then" here.
  • One is "at that time" and the other is "in that case" or "therefore".
  • "Sorry I haven't called you then" is not possible in the first meaning.
  • It is possible in the second meaning.
  • "Sorry I didn't call you then" is possible in both meanings.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
There are two possible meanings of "then" here. One is "at that time" and the other is "in that case" or "therefore".

"Sorry I haven't called you then" is not possible in the first meaning. It is possible in the second meaning.

"Sorry I didn't call you then" is possible in both meanings.

Related Questions