0
SalmanBellow Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

The Word Which

Hi, I have a grammar question. I wanted to quote a sentence, or at least half of one, from a well-known writer. Given the inappropriateness of its subject matter and its irrelevance to you being able to answer the question, I will omit the first part of this sentence.

"—and an enormous serpentine line of fans with cameras and autographable memorabilia has formed at the Impressive booth, which line Ms. St. Claire appears for the moment to be ignoring …"

The part of the sentence I'd like to focus on is ", which line." Why isn't it "a line which?" There are countless examples in which this writer does this very thing. He was extremely ridged about grammar, so I very much doubt it's wrong. And maybe I just haven't been doing enough reading, or else not enough attentive reading, but I don't remember other instances of this order of words from other writers.

Can somebody explain? Thank you.
  

Top answer

SalmanBellow which line ... a line which Both are possible and correct. CJ

  • SalmanBellow which line ...
  • a line which Both are possible and correct.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
SalmanBellowwhich line ... a line which
Both are possible and correct.

CJ
0
Fascinating. Thank you. Now using this example, what if I wanted to add in the word "obviously" to my own example?

"which fortune has done little to curtail my humble side."

Where would the word "obviously" go in there?

"obviously which fortune"

"which obviously fortune"

"which fortune obviously"

"has done little obviously"

Or somethin
0
SalmanBellowNow using this example, what if I wanted to add in the word "obviously" to my own example?
"which fortune has obviously done" is what you want.

In this construction 'which' is a determiner just as 'a' or 'the' is. Therefore you cannot say 'which obviously fortune' any more than you can say 'an obviously apple'.

CJ
0
Fair enough. I didn't realize.

I have had a lot a luck in accumalating this fortune (which fortune has done little to curtail my humble side).

So is it still "which fortune obviously?"

Thank you.
0
SalmanBellowI have had a lot a luck in accumulating this fortune (which fortune has obviously done little to curtail my humble side).
As shown above.

I revised my answer above because I realized I had misread your question. Please read my previous answer again.

You shoul
0
CalifJimTherefore you cannot say 'which obviously fortune
OK, but what makes "which fortune has obviously" better than "which fortune obviously has?"

Are both gramatically correct? And if so, why did you pick "which fortune has obviously" as your preference? Thanks.
0
SalmanBellowAre both gramatically correct?
Yes.
SalmanBellowwhy did you pick "which fortune has obviously" as your preference?
It's the most normal position for an adverb — after the auxiliary 'have'.

CJ
0
Thank you! Feel free to proceed with your day, sir. This matter is closed and solved.

Related Questions