0
Nkspb Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

The Past Simple/Continuous with a while/when clause

Hello.
Help me, please, with this sentence:

"I was writing a letter when she was cooking."

Does it imply that I was writing the letter the same amount of time as she was cooking, or it simply says that at some point when she was cooking I was writing that letter, not necessarily all the time?

Thanks!
  

Top answer

It would be- " I was writing a letter while she was cooking " nkspb it simply says that at some point when she was cooking I was writing that letter, not necessarily all the time Yes, it implies that.

  • It would be- " I was writing a letter while she was cooking " nkspb it simply says that at some point when she was cooking I was writing that letter, not necessarily all the time Yes, it implies that.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
It would be-

" I was writing a letter while she was cooking "
nkspbit simply says that at some point when she was cooking I was writing that letter, not necessarily all the time
Yes, it implies that.
0
nkspbHelp me, please, with this sentence: "I was writing a letter when she was cooking."
More likely: I was writing a letter while she was cooking.
nkspbDoes it imply that I was writing the letter the same amount of time as she was cooking
No. There may be overlap. There was at least some time when both acti
0
Thanks CJ, for the answer and links.
I'd like to clarify something, please. If one says:

"I wrote a letter while she was cooking."

Does it necessarily imply that they finished writing the letter?
0
nkspbDoes it necessarily imply that I finished writing the letter?
Not necessarily. However, most people would reach that conclusion.

It's not a matter of applying strict logic; it's a matter of what seems most probable.

A native speaker would think that if the speaker wanted to indicate that he had not finished the letter, he would s

Related Questions