0
Volcano1985 Posted 17 years ago
Grammar
The now-extinct sabre-tooth cat ----
The now-extinct sabre-tooth cat ---- one of the
most dangerous creatures ever ---- in the
world.
A) is / having lived
B) was / to have lived
C) had been / to live
D) would be / to be living
E) has been / living
I think A
most dangerous creatures ever ---- in the
world.
A) is / having lived
B) was / to have lived
C) had been / to live
D) would be / to be living
E) has been / living
I think A
Top answer
I think it's a grey area. " Probably "B" is better. It depends on whether you're talking about the concept or the reality.
- I think it's a grey area.
- " Probably "B" is better.
- It depends on whether you're talking about the concept or the reality.
- " But is it really?
- I don't think you can say that "B" is incorrect.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
5 Answers
0
I think it's a grey area. Many people would say "A." Probably "B" is better.
It depends on whether you're talking about the concept or the reality.
You could point to a recreation in a museum and say, "That is a sabre-tooth cat."
But is it really?
It depends on whether you're talking about the concept or the reality.
You could point to a recreation in a museum and say, "That is a sabre-tooth cat."
But is it really?
00
Hi,
B is best.
'Was' is better than 'is' because we are explicitly told that the cat is now extinct, which focuses our thoughts on the past.
I've always heard 'sabre-tooth tiger'. 'A sabre-tooth cat'is, of course, not wrong, but it maks me think of a house pet gone bad.
B is best.
'Was' is better than 'is' because we are explicitly told that the cat is now extinct, which focuses our thoughts on the past.
I've always heard 'sabre-tooth tiger'. 'A sabre-tooth cat'is, of course, not wrong, but it maks me think of a house pet gone bad.
00
The now-extinct sabre-tooth cat was one of the most dangerous creatures which had ever lived in the world.
ever to have lived = which had ever lived ?
ever to have lived = which had ever lived ?
00
Hi,
ever to have lived focuses my thoughts on the period up until now.
which had ever lived focuses my thoughts on the period up until the animal became extinct.
Clive
ever to have lived focuses my thoughts on the period up until now.
which had ever lived focuses my thoughts on the period up until the animal became extinct.
Clive
00
CliveI've always heard 'sabre-tooth tiger'.Just for clarification it drives paleontologists nuts when people use the term "saber-tooth tiger" they insist on "cat" since the animals weren't in fact tigers at all, not even close.
From the UCMP site:
0
Related Questions