0
Navitasan Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

The idea of...

Can one use:

1) He mocks extraterrestrial life.

instead of:

2) He mocks the idea of extraterrestrial life.


Can one use:

3) His philosophical essay concentrates on potential loss.

instead of:

4) His philosophical essay concentrates on the idea of potential loss.


Gratefully,

Navi

  

Top answer

It's easier to make the logical leap in the second one. navitasan 1) He mocks extraterrestrial life. 2) He mocks the idea of extraterrestrial life.

  • It's easier to make the logical leap in the second one.
  • navitasan 1) He mocks extraterrestrial life.
  • 2) He mocks the idea of extraterrestrial life.
  • Sentence 1) presupposes the existence of extraterrestrial life.
  • Sentence 2) does not.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

It's easier to make the logical leap in the second one.

navitasan1) He mocks extraterrestrial life. ...
2) He mocks the idea of extraterrestrial life.

Sentence 1) presupposes the existence of extraterrestrial life.
Sentence 2) does not.
Therefore, I would not use the first if I meant the second.

navitasan3) His

Related Questions