0
Reegis Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

The concept of human rights is fairly new in our history.

Hello,

please let's have a look at the sentence:

The concept of human rights is fairly new in our history.

Can we transform it into the sentence below?

The human rights concept is fairly new in our history.

My understanding is that "human rights" would be together treated as a noun modifier - is it correct?
  

Top answer

It' OK, but the original is better.

  • It' OK, but the original is better.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
It' OK, but the original is better.
0
ReegisCan we transform it into the sentence below?
The human rights concept is fairly new in our history.
You can, but you shouldn't.
ReegisMy understanding is that "human rights" would be together treated as a noun modifier - is it correct?
There's room for that interpretation, I suppose. Nevertheless, "human" is an ad
0
CalifJimNevertheless, "human" is an adjective, and "rights" is a noun, so you may meet with some opposition in combining both into what you call a noun.
It never crossed my mind
0
Reegishuman rights can be treated as a noun modifier, which (I hope) means that it is a modifier for a noun or a modifier that describes a noun
Yes. It is an NP (noun phrase) modifier. (Maybe I misunderstood earlier.)

[ [humanadj rightsnoun]NP conceptnoun]NP

CJ
0
Now crystal clear:) I studied mathematics so your description is perfect for me.

Could you please also comment if this second sentence sounds natural to you?
0
ReegisCould you please also comment if this second sentence sounds natural to you?
???

I wrote (above) You can, but you shouldn't.

That means no, it doesn't sound natural to me.

CJ
0
Linguistic rules are not so rigorous/scientific and I must admit that I don't always understand what it means that I shouldn't use a given setence. I think that sometimes people mean by this that it is not grammatically correct, or does not sound natural, or they just don't like it for some subjective reason that might not be shared by other natives.

Nevetheless, I will remember what it m

Related Questions