0
Navitasan Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

The coat in the suitcase that...

Are these sentences correct:

1-The coat in the suitcase that had stained sleeves belonged to me.
2-The coat in the suitcase, which had stained sleeves belonged to me.
In each case, the coat has stained sleeves. In 1 the clause is defining (there are more than one coats) and in 2 non-defining (there is only one coat).

3-I repaired the wheel of the bicycle that was warped.
4-I repaired the front wheel of the bicycle, which was warped.
In each case the wheel is warped. In 3 the clause is defining (restrictive) and in 4 non-defining (non-restrictive).

Gratefully,
Navi.
  

Top answer

It sounds like the suitcase had stained sleeves and the bike was warped. I'd say: 1. The coat with the stained sleeves in the suitcase belonged to me.

  • It sounds like the suitcase had stained sleeves and the bike was warped.
  • I'd say: 1.
  • The coat with the stained sleeves in the suitcase belonged to me.
  • 2.
  • I repaired the warped front wheel of the bicycle.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
It sounds like the suitcase had stained sleeves and the bike was warped.

I'd say:

1. The coat with the stained sleeves in the suitcase belonged to me.

2. I repaired the warped front wheel of the bicycle.

Rover
0
In the first sentence, you have 3 elements - coat, stained sleeves, and suitcase - which makes for a complex single sentence.
The coat with the stained sleeves, in the suitcase, belonged to me.

I repaired the bicycle wheel, which was warped.
Think of th

Related Questions