0
Vincent Teo Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

The bircage is outside the window / near the window

Can I say,
(a) The birdcage is hanging beside the window.
(b) The bird is hanging outside near the window.
(c) The birdcage is out of the window / in front of the window.
(d) The birdcage is hanging outside the window.
  

Top answer

-- OK (b) The bird is singing outside near the window. (c) The birdcage is outside the window / in front of the window. -- OK

  • -- OK (b) The bird is singing outside near the window.
  • (c) The birdcage is outside the window / in front of the window.
  • -- OK
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
.
(a) The birdcage is hanging beside the window.-- OK
(b) The bird is singing outside near the window.
(c) The birdcage is outside the window / in front of the window.
(d) The birdcage is hanging outside the window.-- OK
0
Thanks. But, I thought "beside the window" is incorrect, what do you think? It's weird.

P/s: Why don't we say, "... hanging outside near the window" .
0
.
You can hang a birdcage (given the right fixtures) in many positions vis-a-vis a window. I see nothing wrong with any sentences I have not marked so.
.
0
I mean:

(b) The bird is hanging outside near the window.

Why is that incorrect?
0
.
The bird is perched in the cage; the cage is hanging.
.
0
Thanks. So , if I say,

The birdcage is hanging outside near the window.

How about the sentence?
0
.
Yes, I cannot argue with that, Vincent.
.

Related Questions