0
Wholegrain Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

The beef is a source.

I would like to say: "The beef is a source." instead of being more precise and say "The beef is a source of meat." We can do that even if it sounds awkward right, as it is just imprecise, but still correct?
  

Top answer

"The beef is a source" would be extrememly confusing. Even "The beef is a source of meat" is awkward. " Beef is meat.

  • "The beef is a source" would be extrememly confusing.
  • Even "The beef is a source of meat" is awkward.
  • " Beef is meat.
  • " But just saying "the cow is a source" would be very strange.
  • I'm really not sure what you are trying to say.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
"The beef is a source" would be extrememly confusing. Even "The beef is a source of meat" is awkward. Beef is not "a source of meat." Beef is meat. You could say "Cattle are a source of meat" or "the cow is a source of meat." But just saying "the cow is a source" would be very strange. I'm really not sure what you are trying to say.
0
Regardless that it is strange, we can still say "the cow is a source" right?
0
You would need to say "The Beef is a source of meat.", but this is not quite right: beef is a type of meat, not a source of meat.

You could say "Cattle are a source of meat".

"Cattle are/Beef is a source." is unlikely but theoretically possible when the thing it's a source of has just been mentioned. For example:

You need to make sure you get
0
Isn't saying "Cattle is a source." instead of "Cattle is a source of meat." exactly like saying "Having *** is an act." instead of "Having *** is an act of passion."?

Why can't we merely say "Cattle is a source"?????
0
A source has to be a source of something. As I mentioned, if that something is apparent from context then "X is/are a source." is possible. This tends to sound a bit abrupt, though, so it's more usual to say what it's a source of in the same sentence, either explicitly or using a pronoun such as "this".

It should be "Cattle are..."

Incidentally, "Having *** is an ac
0
What? Can't we say either cattle are or cattle is?
0
Ok, so we can't say the beef are a source of meat?
0
wholegrainOk, so we can't say the beef are a source of meat?
"Beef" (in this sense) is uncountable, so it should be "beef is".

"the beef is" is also possible, but only if you are talking about a particular batch or type of beef.

We've already established that "Beef is a source of meat" is not a very sensible thing to say.
0
I meant cow. We can only say "cow is a source of meat" right?

Related Questions