0
Park sang joon Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

The analyses of a text #2

The narrator recalls his childhood; he came home from the boarding school for his mother's sudden death.
Now all the funeral finished and when night came, Peggotty came to his room and tells him about his mother in her lifetime.
Peggotty is the only maid in his house.

.......................................
"She was never well," said Peggotty, "for a long time. She was uncertain in her mind, and not happy. When her baby was born, I thought at first she would get better, but she was more delicate, and sunk a little every day. She used to like to sit alone before her baby came, and then she cried, but afterwards she used to sing to it, so soft that I once thought, when I heard her, it was like a voice up in the air, that was rising away.
[David Copperfield by Charles Dickens]
I'd like to know if "it was" implied before "so soft that."
I think "that was rising away" is an object of "thought."
So I was wondering if "that" means "and that it."
Thank you in advance for your help.
  

Top answer

" is adverbial, modifying "sing". "that was rising away" modifies "voice". The object of "thought" is "(that) it was like a voice up in the air".

  • " is adverbial, modifying "sing".
  • "that was rising away" modifies "voice".
  • The object of "thought" is "(that) it was like a voice up in the air".
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
"so soft that ..." is adverbial, modifying "sing".

"that was rising away" modifies "voice". The object of "thought" is "(that) it was like a voice up in the air".
0
Thank you, GPY, for your so very helpful answer. Emotion: smile
Then I was wondering what role the comma plays before "that."
0
park sang joonThen I was wondering what role the comma plays before "that."
To a modern reader (or to me, at least), it makes the clause feel non-defining rather than defining. However, I couldn't say for sure that the author put the comma there for that reason. It may be an older punctuation style, or it may simply be the author's whim.

Related Questions