0
Too finicky 7 Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

Tenses and grammer

Hey, Does this sentence stand correct - I had seen Simran when she was in the first year of college and how excited she used to get when she talked about marriages.

Or should it be i saw Simran

Thanks.

  

Top answer

too finicky 7 should it be I saw Simran ? Both "had seen" and "saw" are grammatically correct, but "had seen" (the past perfect) is a dependent tense, so whether that tense is appropriate or not depends on what comes before it in the text. If you're just starting the conversation, you say I saw .

  • too finicky 7 should it be I saw Simran ?
  • Both "had seen" and "saw" are grammatically correct, but "had seen" (the past perfect) is a dependent tense, so whether that tense is appropriate or not depends on what comes before it in the text.
  • If you're just starting the conversation, you say I saw .
  • If you've been talking about Simran and saying things about what she's been doing more recently than college, and then you want to talk about when she was in college, which was earlier, you say I had seen .
  • You use the past perfect when you've been talking about the past, and then you want to talk about something even farther in the past.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
too finicky 7should it be I saw Simran?

Both "had seen" and "saw" are grammatically correct, but "had seen" (the past perfect) is a dependent tense, so whether that tense is appropriate or not depends on what comes before it in the text.

If you're just startin

Related Questions