0
Abdul Kaium Tanvir Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Tense

1.I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake , but I can't eat as my doctor had advised me to watch my weight.

2.I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake, but I can't eat as my doctor have advised me to watch my weight.

3.I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake, but I can't eat as my doctor advised me to watch my weight.


Which one/s is/are correct?
  

Top answer

I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake , but I can't eat IT as my doctor had advised me to watch my weight. Not really - 'had' suggests a completed action and the weight-watching is no longer relevant, so it is not a problem to eat the cake now, in the present. Notice I've added 'it' to each sentence as otherwise you're saying you can't eat anything!

  • I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake , but I can't eat IT as my doctor had advised me to watch my weight.
  • Not really - 'had' suggests a completed action and the weight-watching is no longer relevant, so it is not a problem to eat the cake now, in the present.
  • Notice I've added 'it' to each sentence as otherwise you're saying you can't eat anything!
  • I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake, but I can't eat IT as my doctor have advised me to watch my weight.
  • No.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Abdul Kaium Tanvir1.I am tempted by the sumptuous chocolate cake , but I can't eat IT as my doctor had advised me to watch my weight.

Not really - 'had' suggests a completed action and the weight-watching is no longer relevant, so it is not a problem to eat the cake now, in the present.

Notice I've added 'it' to each sentence as otherwise you're sayin

0
A, had is correct answer.

Related Questions