0
Vincent Teo Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Sweet in the basket

Can I say,

The apples are sweet in the basket.
  

Top answer

It has no meaning for me. Do you mean 'The apples (that are) in the basket are sweet'?

  • It has no meaning for me.
  • Do you mean 'The apples (that are) in the basket are sweet'?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
It has no meaning for me. Do you mean 'The apples (that are) in the basket are sweet'?
0
Dear Vincent

In everyday speech, Mr M is right

But your phrase works in poetry or song

There is an Irish song that has..

- Milk lies sweet in a hundred pails
And apples in the basket

The writer only wants seven syllables in that last line but if he'd had more, he could have written..

- Milk lies sweet in a hundred pails

The app
0
Yes, I mean 'The apples (that) are in the basket are sweet'.

Can I say like that way?
0
Hi

If there are some apples in a basket that are sweet, then this is natural..

- The apples in that basket are sweet

Sorry if my earlier reply was confusing. The phrase also means that apples that are freshly picked - in the picker's basket - will taste sweeter than ones bought in a supermarket. (But I guess you didn't mean that..)

Best regards, Dave
0
Thanks, do my sentence correct?

The apples are sweet in the basket.
0
Dear Vincent

It's difficult for me to answer

If I was walking past a market-trader and he said "The apples are sweet in the basket!" then I would know exactly what he meant and I might buy some. I would understand him, in part, because of the phrases mentioned above

If I were an ESL teacher (which I am not) I might say: "in the basket" is an adjectival phrase and, in th
0
Dear Vicent

The way you mentioned conveys another meaning. It is thought that the apples are sweet JUST in the basket.

But the way Mistre Micawber has mentioned is logical.

Hope it helps you

Iman

Related Questions