0
Bluejay Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

Such as

He carries a bag such as a doctor carries.

Is "such" an adjective modifying bag?
  

Top answer

He carries a bag such as a doctor carries. Nobody seems to be answering this. Elipsis is stylish these days.

  • He carries a bag such as a doctor carries.
  • Nobody seems to be answering this.
  • Elipsis is stylish these days.
  • He carries a bag like [the bag] a doctor carries.
  • " The whole (prepositional) phrase "like the bag a doctor carries" modifies "bag," which is object of the verb.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

22 Answers
0
He carries a bag such as a doctor carries.

Nobody seems to be answering this.

Elipsis is stylish these days.
He carries a bag like [the bag] a doctor carries.
The phrase "such as" equals "like."
The whole (prepositional) phrase "like the bag a doctor carries" modifies "bag," which is object of the verb.
"
0
BluejayHe carries a bag such as a doctor carries.
Is "such" an adjective modifying bag? Yes. Did you get this straight out of the dictionary?

Main Entry: 1such

Pronunciation: \'s?ch, 'sich\

Function: adjective

Etymology: Middle English, from Old English swilc; akin to Old High Ge
0
Thank you very much for the responses. (Yes, the example sentence was taken from the dictionary)

He carries a bag such as a doctor carries.

Would I be correct to state that "as" is a relative (?) pronoun introducing the adjective clause?
0
Okay, guys. I really blew this one, didn't I?

I can hear is as an adjective in some structures:

You are beautiful. You are such and so. Okay.

You are such a bag! No. Is this an adjective?

You are such that I can no longer live with you. Okay,maybe.

Why do I have such trouble placing the adjective after the noun i
0
Main Entry: as
Function: pronoun
Date: 12th century
1 : that, who, which -used after same or such<in the same building as my brother> <tears such as angels weep - John Milton> ...

Though it is a pronoun according to the dictionary entry shown above, as is not commonly called a relative pronoun, but it does function somewhat like that, s
0
AvangiWhy do I have such trouble placing the adjective after the noun it modifies?
such may be unique. such has a complex grammar. Not all of its uses can be reconciled with the more familiar grammatical patterns we are used to seeing.

CJ
0
Okay, "tears such as angels weep" is the same as the OP. I'll buy that. My ear has no problem, but the nomenclature is completely new to me: adj; ****.

Edit. Thanks, Jim. I wrote this before I saw your latest.
0
Hi,
Can I say:

He carries such a bag as a doctor does.
0
He carries such a bag as a doctor does.

Hi, LiJ,
Jim's gone off site.

In my opinion this version is also correct, and I would not hesitate to use it.
However, it is a bit uncommon.

Perhaps MrM will comment.
0
Thanks so much, Avangi!

Can I omit the first "a"?

Related Questions