substitute

5 Alan was substituted with Peter (Peter in action now)

6 I substituted Alan with Peter (Peter in action now)

Do you agree?

7 Alan was substituted by Peter (Peter in action now)

Anybody?

Please

All seem fine to me.

Hi,

Hi,

1 Alan was substituted for Peter. (Alan in action now)

2 Alan substituted for Peter (Alan in action now)

3 I substituted Alan for Peter (Alan in action now)

4 I substituted Alan with Peter. (Peter in action now)

I agree with Clive's objection to "now."

However, a search at Yahoo with:
"substituted with" bbc
gives many BBC articles with "substituted with," such as:

1301 BST: The second half gets under way with the noise level pumped
up once more. Hong Myung-Bo is substituted with Kim Tae-Young coming
on in his place.

This is not an example of "substituted with". It means (a) Hon Myung-Bo is substituted (b) Kim Tae-Young comes on in his place. This "with" means "in a situation in which".
Other examples:
They formed a committee, with Mr Brown acting as chairman.
A new agreement was reached, with Germany and France dicating the conditions.

J LewisThis is not an example of "substituted with". It means (a) Hon Myung-Bo is substituted (b) Kim Tae-Young comes on in his place. This "with" means "in a situation in which".

Ah, you mean they missed a comma before "with?" That is possible.

OK, I think this is a legitimate "substitute with":

----------
THE BBC was yesterday accused of bowing to Labour after it changed its coverage of the Government's Euro-manifesto launch to tone down the party's enthusiasm for the EU.

In a report of the Labour manifesto launch for the lunchtime news, a
BBC graphic picked out the document's four main points, all

CliveHi,

Hi,

1 Alan was substituted for Peter. (Alan in action now)

2 Alan substituted for Peter (Alan in action now)

3 I substituted Alan for Peter (Alan in action now)

4 I substituted Alan with Peter. (Peter in action