0
JIM1984 Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Subordinate clauses and conjunctions

'A wise enough fellow, then how come he behaved so stupidly? Is it correct to conclude that 'How come he behaved so stupidly?' , of and by itself, is a a grammatically correct sentence, but that the same sentence only with 'That' as the headword would not (e.g. Then how come he behaved so stupidly?) be considered a grammatically correct sentence. Alternatively, would 'Then how come he behaved so stupidly' be OK if a comma was insteted immediately after Then (as in Then,...stupidly?) More specifically, when with short sentences beginning with a conjunction (But, And, etc) is a commma essential after the conjunction and before the bona fide sentence following (e.g. 'But, I don't know.' as opposed to 'But I don't know (without the comma). I'm sorry to go on, but it's a small point that I need to have hammered home to me - so to round off, is 'A wise enough fellow, then, how come he behaved so stupidly?' correct ( I know 'then' is an adverb and not a conjunction, but I'm thinking the same rule applies to 'then' and would be applied to a conjunction)? I'm sorry if it goes on a bit, but what can you do sometimes?
  

Top answer

JIM1984 A wise enough fellow, then how come he behaved so stupidly? " If/since he's so smart, [then] why does he act stupidly? If you do your part, [then] I'll do my part.

  • JIM1984 A wise enough fellow, then how come he behaved so stupidly?
  • " If/since he's so smart, [then] why does he act stupidly?
  • If you do your part, [then] I'll do my part.
  • Since you did your part, [then] I'll do my part.
  • "Then" is optional.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
JIM1984A wise enough fellow, then how come he behaved so stupidly?
I wouldn't add a comma after "then."

If/since he's so smart, [then] why does he act stupidly?

If you do your part, [then] I'll do my part. Since you did your part, [then] I'll do my part.

"Then" is optional. I'm not as sure as you are about its part of speech.
0
It's an interesting enough reply, but could you tell me, in plain English (either yea or nay) if the sentnece 'But I don't know.' is a grammatically correct sentence regardless of their not being a comma after the conjunction (But). I mean in respect of you or anyone else whose around to answer. Thanks.
0
JIM1984But I don't know.
The usage board would probably be split on this. There are more than enough rules to go around, and I'm sure the grammar school teacher advised us not to begin a sentence with "But." "But Miss Ainsworth!"
There are various levels of acceptability. Some of your examples seem to be of casual conversation which is rather stylized

Related Questions